- Home
- Courses
- AQA A-Level Maths
- Proof
- Proof by Deduction
Proof by Deduction
Proof by deduction is the direct route: start from a general case, do honest algebra, and rearrange until the property you want is staring back at you. It is the technique behind most “Show that…” marks on Paper 1.
The big picture
If the previous lesson gave you the vocabulary of proof, deduction is the first full sentence you build with it. Nearly every “prove” question that is not obviously a counter-example or a contradiction is a deduction — you take a general object, transform it with algebra you already trust, and reveal that it must have the required property. The skill is not the algebra itself; it is choosing the manipulation that makes the answer visible.
What you'll be able to do
- Prove a general statement directly by starting from a suitable algebraic form
- Reveal “even”, “odd” or “multiple of ” by factoring out the right number
- Prove inequalities such as by completing the square
- Write a deduction that a reader can follow line by line to a clear conclusion
The idea: transform, don’t test
A deductive proof works forwards. You represent the general case algebraically, apply valid steps — expanding, factorising, completing the square — and arrive at a form that visibly has the property you were asked to prove. No cases, no assumptions, no examples: just a clean chain from the general to the specific claim.
The whole art is choosing the target form. If you must prove something is , aim to write it as . If it must be a , aim for . If it must be , aim for a square plus a positive number. Knowing the destination tells you which manipulation to reach for.
Factoring out a 2 is not a trick — it is the definition of even made visible. “ something whole” and “even” are literally the same statement, so once you reach that form the proof is finished.
The playbook
Four moves handle almost every deduction:
the general case with algebra (e.g. an odd number as ). or combine everything into a single expression. towards the target — pull out a 2, a 3, or complete the square. by naming the property and referring back to the claim.
Example 1Prove that the square of any odd number is odd.
Revealing “multiple of $k$”
Statements about multiples are proved the same way — do the algebra, then factor out the number you need. The trick is to keep everything in one variable and resist the urge to test values.
Example 1Prove that the sum of the squares of two consecutive integers is always odd.
Example 2Prove that the difference between the squares of two consecutive integers is odd, and equals their sum.
Tip — If the target is “multiple of 4”, don’t stop at a factor of 2 — keep factorising until a 4 (or the exact number asked) is showing.
Proving inequalities by completing the square
A whole family of AQA proofs asks you to show an expression is always positive, or always at least some value. Testing numbers is useless here — you need to show it for real . The tool is completing the square, because a squared bracket can never be negative.
Once you write an expression as , the term for all real , so the whole expression is at least . That single fact proves the inequality in one line.
Example 1Prove that for all real values of .
The value of after completing the square is the minimum of the expression. So this method does more than prove positivity — it tells you the smallest value the expression can ever take, and the at which it happens.
Think like an examiner
- The phrase “” is a signal to complete the square, not to try numbers — a square bracket is the only clean way to argue about every real value at once.
- When proving “multiple of ”, the mark for the conclusion requires the factor of to be . Write explicitly rather than leaving it as .
- State that the leftover bracket “is an integer” before you call the result even/odd — examiners look for that justification.
- A concluding sentence tying back to the question (“…so the expression is always positive”) is frequently the final mark.
Common misconceptions
Deduction toolkit
Stretch yourself
Prove that is a multiple of 6 for every integer . (Hint: factorise first, then think about what three consecutive integers must contain.)
Hint — Factorise . Among any three consecutive integers, how many are even, and how many are multiples of 3?
Reveal solution
Questions students ask
When should I use proof by deduction rather than another method?
How do I know what to factorise towards?
Why does completing the square prove an inequality when substituting numbers doesn’t?
Is it okay to split into cases in a deduction?
Key takeaways
- Deduction is a direct, forward argument from a general case to the claim.
- Choose the target form: for even, for a multiple of , a square constant for positivity.
- Represent, expand, factorise, conclude — and justify that the leftover is an integer.
- Prove “for all real ” inequalities by completing the square, using .
- Finish with a sentence that names the property and refers back to the statement.
How this fits the course
Test yourself
Answer a few questions, then review anything you missed.
Prefer paper? Open the written self-check
Answer each question before opening its answer. This self-check does not record a quiz score.
To prove an expression is even, you should rewrite it in the form:
- a completed square
Show answer and explanation
Answer:
“Even” means exactly “a multiple of 2”, i.e. .
Completing the square, becomes:
Show answer and explanation
Answer:
.
Which statement correctly justifies that for all real ?
- , so adding 4 gives at least 4, which is .
- always, so it is .
- Substituting gives 20, which is positive.
- A quadratic is always positive.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: , so adding 4 gives at least 4, which is .
A square is (it can be 0). The constant is what guarantees the total is strictly positive.
The difference between the squares of two consecutive integers is:
- always odd
- always even
- always a multiple of 4
- sometimes odd, sometimes even
Show answer and explanation
Answer: always odd
, which is odd for every integer .
In proving is odd, the correct factorised form is:
Show answer and explanation
Answer:
— one more than an even number, hence odd.
Which is the best first step to prove is a multiple of 6?
- Factorise it as .
- Substitute .
- Complete the square.
- Assume it is not a multiple of 6.
Show answer and explanation
Answer: Factorise it as .
Factorising reveals three consecutive integers, which must contain a factor of 2 and a factor of 3, hence of 6.
Keep practising
Start with the quiz above to check the key ideas. You can also choose another topic from the practice library.
Related lessons
All 6 lessons- Same chapterThe Structure of a Mathematical ProofWhat a proof actually is: statements, conditions, the logic symbols ⇒, ⇐ and ⇔, and the standard number sets.
- Same chapterProof by ExhaustionSplitting a statement into every possible case and checking each one, and knowing when that approach is valid.
- Same chapterDisproof by Counter-ExampleWhy a single well-chosen example can destroy a claim, and how to hunt for one efficiently.
Put the methods into practice: see how A-Level maths duels work. An account is required to play; the overview and sample are public.