166–167Nuclear PhysicsStretch

Fission and Fusion

A nuclear power station splits uranium nuclei; the Sun joins hydrogen nuclei. Fission\textbf{Fission} and fusion\textbf{fusion} sound like opposites, yet both release energy for the same reason — the products are more tightly bound than what went in.

40 min Topic 11 · Nuclear Radiation

What you'll be able to do

  • Calculate the energy released in fission and fusion reactions from mass differences
  • Describe a chain reaction and the roles of the moderator, control rods and coolant
  • Explain why fusion requires very high temperatures and densities
  • Compare fission and fusion as energy sources
1

Nuclear fission

In induced fission\textbf{induced fission}, a heavy nucleus such as uranium-235 absorbs a slow neutron, becomes unstable, and splits into two medium-mass daughter nuclei plus two or three fast neutrons.

A typical reaction is 92235U+ 01n→ 56141Ba+ 3692Kr+3 01n^{235}_{92}\mathrm{U} +\ ^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n} \rightarrow\ ^{141}_{56}\mathrm{Ba} +\ ^{92}_{36}\mathrm{Kr} + 3\,^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n}. The daughters vary from one event to the next, but nucleon and proton numbers always balance.

Each fission releases about 200 MeV, mostly as kinetic energy of the fragments, which becomes thermal energy in the fuel.

Example 1For the reaction above, the masses are: U-235 235.04393 u; n 1.00867 u; Ba-141 140.91441 u; Kr-92 91.92617 u. Find the energy released in MeV.
1Before: 235.04393+1.00867=236.05260235.04393 + 1.00867 = 236.05260 u.
2After: 140.91441+91.92617+3(1.00867)=235.86659140.91441 + 91.92617 + 3(1.00867) = 235.86659 u.
3Mass decrease: 0.186010.18601 u; ×931.5\times 931.5.
Answer173 MeV173\ \mathrm{MeV}

Tip — Count the neutrons on both sides. Forgetting that one neutron goes in while three come out is the most common error.

2

Chain reactions and reactors

The neutrons released can trigger further fissions — a chain reaction\textbf{chain reaction}. For a steady output, exactly one neutron from each fission must go on to cause another. More than one and the reaction grows out of control; fewer and it dies away.

The moderator\textbf{moderator}, often water or graphite, slows fast neutrons through collisions so they are much more likely to be absorbed by U-235. The best moderators have nuclei of similar mass to a neutron, so each collision transfers a large fraction of its kinetic energy.

Control rods\textbf{Control rods}, made of boron or cadmium, absorb neutrons. Lowering them reduces the number of neutrons available and slows the reaction. The coolant\textbf{coolant} carries thermal energy away to generate steam.

A minimum critical mass\textbf{critical mass} of fuel is needed; with less, too many neutrons escape through the surface for the chain to sustain itself.

3

Nuclear fusion

In fusion\textbf{fusion}, two light nuclei join to form a heavier one. A reaction proposed for reactors is deuterium–tritium fusion: 12H+ 13H→ 24He+ 01n^{2}_{1}\mathrm{H} +\ ^{3}_{1}\mathrm{H} \rightarrow\ ^{4}_{2}\mathrm{He} +\ ^{1}_{0}\mathrm{n}.

Both nuclei are positive, so they repel. To get close enough for the strong force to act — about 10−1510^{-15} m — they need enough kinetic energy to overcome that electrostatic barrier.

That requires temperatures of the order of 10710^{7} to 10810^{8} K, at which matter is a plasma\textbf{plasma} of bare nuclei and electrons. A high density is also needed so collisions are frequent enough to produce useful power.

Example 1Find the energy released in D–T fusion. Masses: 2H^{2}\mathrm{H} 2.01355 u; 3H^{3}\mathrm{H} 3.01550 u; 4He^{4}\mathrm{He} 4.00151 u; n 1.00867 u.
1Before: 2.01355+3.01550=5.029052.01355 + 3.01550 = 5.02905 u.
2After: 4.00151+1.00867=5.010184.00151 + 1.00867 = 5.01018 u.
3Mass decrease: 0.018870.01887 u; ×931.5\times 931.5.
Answer17.6 MeV17.6\ \mathrm{MeV}

Tip — Per reaction, fission releases more energy. Per kilogram of fuel, fusion wins, because its reactants are so light.

4

Comparing the two

Fission is established technology, providing about a tenth of the world’s electricity with no carbon dioxide emissions from generation. Its drawbacks are long-lived radioactive waste and the need to contain the risk of accidents.

Fusion fuel — deuterium from seawater, and tritium bred from lithium — is plentiful, and fusion produces no long-lived fission products. But confining a plasma at over 10810^{8} K with magnetic fields, and producing more energy than is put in, remains extremely difficult.

Stars solve the confinement problem with gravity: their immense mass holds the plasma together at the necessary density and temperature for billions of years.

Equation recap

E=Δm×931.5 MeV u−1E = \Delta m \times 931.5\ \mathrm{MeV\,u^{-1}}
Energy released.
ΔE=c2Δm\Delta E = c^{2}\Delta m
In SI units.

Common mistakes to avoid

Saying the moderator absorbs neutrons.
The moderator slows neutrons; control rods absorb them.
Saying fusion needs high temperature to "melt" nuclei.
High kinetic energy overcomes electrostatic repulsion.
Forgetting product neutrons in the mass calculation.
Include every particle on each side.
Saying fission releases energy because nuclei get heavier.
Products have higher binding energy per nucleon and less total mass.

Key takeaways

  • Fission splits heavy nuclei; fusion joins light ones. Both move products up the binding energy curve.
  • Energy released == mass decrease ×c2\times c^{2}, or ×931.5\times 931.5 MeV per u.
  • Reactors control a chain reaction with moderator, control rods and coolant.
  • Fusion needs very high temperature to overcome electrostatic repulsion, and high density.
  • Fusion releases more energy per kilogram; fission more per reaction.

Test yourself

Answer a few questions, then review anything you missed.

Next step

Keep practising

Start with the quiz above to check the key ideas. You can also choose another topic from the practice library.

Browse practice topics

Related lessons

All 4 lessons